Celebrating Service, Joy, and Excellence: Faculty Awards from the Fall Semester
Each fall, Portsmouth Christian Academy pauses to recognize the faculty and staff members whose daily faithfulness, joyful service, and Christ-centered leadership shape our community in lasting ways. The Fall 2025 Faculty and Staff Awards honor individuals who have gone above and beyond their roles, inspired joy, led with humility, pursued excellence, and blazed new trails for our students and school.
These awards are more than acknowledgments of hard work. They reflect the heart of PCA, a community where service is offered with joy, leadership is rooted in humility, and every role matters.
Above and Beyond Award
The Above and Beyond Award recognizes those who extend themselves beyond what is expected, doing so with joy, good spirit, and a willingness to serve wherever needed.
This fall, Erin Murtagh was honored for her initiative and care for students. While serving as a part-time Lower School teacher’s aide, Erin took it upon herself to design and implement a digital report card for second grade over the summer months. Her work went well beyond her role, resulting in a tool that supported teachers and families during first quarter reporting, all while continuing to provide excellent, attentive care to students.
Shelly Walker was recognized for championing more than 100 elementary learners through her work as a classroom aide. Known for her strong work ethic and quiet leadership, Shelly consistently steps in to support others, assisting with copying, correcting, and preparation across classrooms. Her unprompted service and mentorship strengthen the entire Lower School team.
Laurie Underwood received the award for her exceptional dedication as PCA’s IT Director. During a season of significant program changes, Laurie consistently made time to listen, problem-solve, and support staff with patience and care. Her perseverance in researching tools and finding solutions reflects a servant’s heart and has had a meaningful impact across the school.
Tammy Treadwell was honored for her steadfast love for students and enduring service to PCA. With years of experience and deep institutional knowledge, Tammy supports fellow teachers with wisdom and humor, tutors students before and after school, and faithfully attends student events. Her generosity of time and spirit reflects a life of service rooted in love for God and others.
Joyful Impact Award
The Joyful Impact Award celebrates those whose work consistently inspires joy and fosters a culture of hope, regardless of circumstances.
Donna Collins received this award for her vision and contributions to the Lower and Middle School library. Through thoughtful design, plants, and inviting reading spaces, Donna transformed the library into a warm, joyful environment that blesses everyone who enters.
Hayley Tammany was recognized for bringing tremendous joy and enthusiasm into a new role this school year. Balancing life as a mother, student, and teacher, Hayley quickly built strong relationships with colleagues, families, and students. Always willing to step in and help, her joyful spirit and eagerness have added warmth and community to the Preschool.
Michelle Poulin was honored for her joyful dedication to PCA’s youngest Eagles. After stepping into a temporary role, Michelle followed God’s leading into a full-time preschool position. Her energy, passion for teaching, and commitment to relationships shine daily, particularly in the strong partnership she built with her new teammate. Her joy is contagious, often expressed through a smile and even a dance move.
Jenn Durham received the Joyful Impact Award for creating a welcoming and caring environment as PCA’s Lead Receptionist. Known affectionately as “Miss Jenn,” she greets students by name, supports her reception team faithfully, and offers hospitality to all who enter the building. From front-desk riddles to thoughtful conversations, Jenn reminds the community that they are seen, known, and deeply cared for.
Servant Leader Award
The Servant Leader Award honors those who exemplify Christ-centered humility, compassion, and a commitment to serving others.
Sue McKenney was recognized for her quiet, faithful service in the Lower School Office. Sue offers a listening ear to countless students each day, supports teachers behind the scenes, and faithfully serves the broader community through service projects such as the OCC shoebox drive and coat collection. Her dedication reflects Christ-like love in action.
Harlee Tuttle received the award for her exceptional leadership of the Preschool program. As department head, Harlee supports every teacher and aide with encouragement, attention to detail, and genuine care. Her leadership extends beyond Preschool, connecting students to school-wide events and fostering community pride. Her joyful, steady presence models servant leadership at its best.
Spirit of Excellence Award
The Spirit of Excellence Award recognizes individuals whose sustained efforts and commitment have helped PCA grow and improve.
Betsy Hickey was honored for her faithful dedication to student growth in the four-year-old program. A lifelong learner, Betsy continually seeks professional development opportunities to refine her practice. Her commitment to meeting each child’s needs, partnering with families, and pursuing excellence reflects a deep dedication to her calling as an educator.
Trailblazer Award
The Trailblazer Award celebrates outstanding contributions to a specific project or initiative.
David Miller received multiple nominations for his leadership in PCA’s new partnership with Ethos. David joyfully stepped into a lead coordination role, supporting Upper School students, course learning coordinators, and the program as a whole. His work establishing systems, securing resources, and problem-solving challenges has expanded opportunities for students and strengthened PCA’s STEAM offerings. His heart for student success and willingness to take on new responsibilities exemplify trailblazing leadership.
These faculty and staff members reflect the very best of Portsmouth Christian Academy. Through their service, leadership, joy, and pursuit of excellence, they remind us that every role has purpose and that faithful work done unto the Lord leaves a lasting impact on our community.
